Why Sleep Restriction Alone Isn’t Enough to Cure Insomnia
Sleep restriction is one of the most effective tools we have for improving sleep. It helps to reset the body clock and strengthen your natural sleep drive.
However, on its own, it’s rarely enough to resolve long-term insomnia.
Why? Because while sleep restriction targets the body, it doesn’t address the mind — and our minds are incredibly powerful.
No matter how tired we are, if our vigilance system is switched on, it acts like a brake pedal on our sleepiness, keeping us alert and preventing rest.
To truly restore healthy, refreshing sleep, we need to combine sleep restriction with cognitive and behavioural strategies that calm the mind, lower arousal, and break the mental and emotional patterns that keep us awake.
What sleep restriction does
Sleep restriction works by temporarily limiting the amount of time you spend in bed to match the actual amount of sleep you’re getting. For example, if you’re only sleeping five hours, despite spending eight hours in bed, you might initially be told to restrict your time in bed to five hours. Over time, as your sleep becomes more consolidated, that time is gradually increased.
This process helps to reset the body clock (circadian rhythm) and builds sleep pressure — the natural drive to sleep that increases the longer you’re awake. With consistent use, it can help reduce the time it takes to fall asleep and limit nighttime awakenings.
So why doesn’t it work alone?
Sleep restriction only tackles the biological side of insomnia — it trains the body to sleep more efficiently. But insomnia isn’t just biological; it’s also psychological.
Many people with chronic sleep issues have learned, through repeated nights of frustration, that bed = being awake, worrying, or struggling to sleep. Over time, this creates a strong conditioned association between the bed and wakefulness. So, even when the body is physically ready for sleep, the mind can still be on high alert.
Why cognitive strategies are a must
Cognitive techniques help to undo the learned connection and calm the overactive mind that fuels insomnia. They include:
Reframing unhelpful thoughts (“If I don’t sleep tonight, tomorrow will be a disaster”) to reduce sleep-related anxiety.
Leaning into physical sensations rather than trying to make them disappear or distract from them. This allows feelings to be processed effectively.
Developing a healthier mindset about sleep, shifting from control and performance (“I must sleep”) to acceptance and patience.
Creating positive associations with the bed — using it only for sleep and intimacy - and getting up if you’re lying in bed awake.
When these cognitive approaches are used alongside sleep restriction, they help the brain relearn that bed is a place for rest and safety, not stress and struggle.
The goal: reconnecting mind and body
Ultimately, recovery from insomnia happens when the body’s sleep systems and the mind’s sense of safety and calm work in sync again. Sleep restriction resets your internal rhythm, while cognitive strategies repair the emotional relationship you have with sleep itself.
Used together, they help you rebuild trust in your ability to sleep — naturally, consistently, and without effort.
Free Sleep Webinar: How to fall asleep easily and sleep through the night.
Join Kathryn, founder of the UK’s largest and leading insomnia service, for a short webinar that is guaranteed to give you the confidence to quickly improve your sleep.
In just 30 minutes you will learn
- The 3 things you need to control your sleep.
- How to fall asleep quickly and wake less.
- The number 1 thing you are doing which is sabotaging your sleep.
